By ReefMetric. Page updated: . Equipment data keeps the source dates shown below.
Reviews · Test Kits
Hanna vs Salifert vs Red Sea — the test kit face-off, by published specs
Choose a test that covers the water level you need to measure, then compare its stated accuracy, resolution, and running cost. A reusable colorimeter has an upfront instrument cost plus later reagents; a visual kit bundles its supplies. The table keeps those costs separate.
Paid links: if you buy through links on this page we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you — it never affects our ratings. How we make money.
Original kit specifications and prices are recorded from 2026-07-11. Hanna refill prices and 25-test refill counts, plus Salifert specification links, were checked on October 25, 2026; no other kit price is described as refreshed. Each row links its specification and price sources. A missing accuracy value means it was not recorded in this dataset. Full methodology →
The one-paragraph verdict
For alkalinity, choose between a digital readout and a visual titration based on the range, procedure, and costs you can sustain. Hanna's HI772 has a recorded $74.99 instrument price; its verified $18.99 refill supplies 25 tests, or $0.76 per later test. The instrument price divided by its starter tests is not the ongoing reagent cost. For other parameters, compare the actual row before choosing a brand.
Alkalinity
Track closely when setting or changing a dosing schedule; adjust frequency to measured consumption.
| Kit | Published accuracy | Resolution | Method | First-kit $/test | Refill $/test | Kit / instrument price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanna HI772 Marine Alkalinity Checker Published specifications 25 reference tests | ±0.3 dKH ±5% of reading | 0.1 dKH | digital colorimeter | $3.00 Includes initial purchase | $0.76 $18.99 / 25 tests Refill source | $74.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Salifert KH/Alk Profi-Test Published specifications 100 reference tests Maker gives approximately 100-200 tests; the startup estimate uses 100. | not published | 0.1 meq/L (about 0.3 dKH) stated step | titration (drop-count, color endpoint) | $0.19 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $18.79 (paid link) ↗ |
| Red Sea KH/Alkalinity Pro Published specifications 75 reference tests | 0.05 meq/L (0.14 dKH) | not published | titration (syringe, color endpoint) | $0.60 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $44.99 (paid link) ↗ |
Calcium
Test alongside alkalinity when setting a dosing schedule.
| Kit | Published accuracy | Resolution | Method | First-kit $/test | Refill $/test | Kit / instrument price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanna HI758 Marine Calcium Checker Published specifications 25 reference tests | ±6 ppm ±5% of reading | 1 ppm | digital colorimeter | $3.00 Includes initial purchase | $1.40 $34.99 / 25 tests Refill source | $74.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Salifert Calcium Profi-Test Published specifications 50 reference tests Maker gives approximately 50-100 tests; the startup estimate uses 50. | not published | 10 mg/L stated step | titration (drop-count, pink→blue endpoint) | $0.44 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $21.79 (paid link) ↗ |
| Red Sea Calcium Pro Published specifications 75 reference tests | 5 ppm | not published | titration (syringe, color endpoint) | $0.60 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $44.99 (paid link) ↗ |
Magnesium
Check when assessing the balance of calcium and alkalinity.
| Kit | Published accuracy | Resolution | Method | First-kit $/test | Refill $/test | Kit / instrument price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanna HI783 Marine Magnesium Checker Published specifications 25 reference tests | ±5% of reading | 5 ppm | digital colorimeter | $3.00 Includes initial purchase | $1.04 $25.99 / 25 tests Refill source | $74.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Salifert Magnesium Profi-Test Published specifications 50 reference tests | not published | 30 mg/L per titration step | titration (drop-count, grey/blue endpoint) | $0.44 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $21.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Red Sea Magnesium Pro Published specifications 100 reference tests | 20 ppm (Red Sea's page; BRS's listing says ±10 ppm — we report the manufacturer's own number) | not published | titration (syringe, color endpoint) | $0.45 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $44.99 (paid link) ↗ |
Phosphate
The algae budget. Low numbers need real resolution to be meaningful.
| Kit | Published accuracy | Resolution | Method | First-kit $/test | Refill $/test | Kit / instrument price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanna HI774 Phosphate ULR Checker Published specifications 10 reference tests | ±0.02 ppm ±5% of reading | 0.01 ppm | digital colorimeter | $7.50 Includes initial purchase | $0.76 $18.99 / 25 tests Refill source | $74.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Salifert Phosphate Profi-Test Published specifications 60 reference tests Retailer lists 60 tests; the maker page says approximately 50. Check the instructions and actual reagent use for your kit. | not published | not published | visual comparator card | $0.37 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $21.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Red Sea Phosphate Pro Published specifications 100 reference tests | ±0.02 ppm | not published | visual comparator card | $0.58 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $57.99 (paid link) ↗ |
Nitrate
The other nutrient — modern reefs run it low but not zero.
| Kit | Published accuracy | Resolution | Method | First-kit $/test | Refill $/test | Kit / instrument price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanna HI781 Marine Nitrate LR Checker Published specifications 25 reference tests | ±0.25 ppm ±2% of reading (0-5 ppm direct; to 50 ppm via dilution) | 0.01 ppm | digital colorimeter | $3.00 Includes initial purchase | $1.00 $24.99 / 25 tests Refill source | $74.99 (paid link) ↗ |
| Salifert Nitrate Profi-Test Published specifications 60 reference tests | not published | not published | visual comparator card | $0.33 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $19.79 (paid link) ↗ |
| Red Sea Nitrate Pro Published specifications 100 reference tests | ±0.125 ppm (BRS listing) | not published | visual comparator card | $0.58 Includes initial purchase | Refill count not verified | $57.99 (paid link) ↗ |
First-kit cost per test = initial kit or instrument price ÷ included test count. Refill cost per test = refill price ÷ the refill's own verified test count. Shipping, tax, wasted tests, expired reagents, and replacement hardware are excluded. Refills are shown only where their count was verified; a starter kit count is never assumed to be the refill count. Resolution describes the reading steps, not an accuracy guarantee.
Check the units before changing the tank
Salifert describes its test as measuring phosphate. Follow the chart and instructions supplied with your kit; do not automatically multiply a phosphate result by a phosphorus conversion factor. Phosphate and phosphorus are different reported quantities. Also check whether a result is in ppm or ppb.
Use the exact sample volume, clean the vial, and check reagent dates. A digital display does not remove technique errors. Repeat an unexpected result before making a dosing change, and compare like units if you cross-check with another kit.
FAQ
Which parameter should I test most often?
Alkalinity is useful to track closely when you set up or change dosing. Test often enough to measure consumption and catch a change, then choose a schedule based on your tank. A fixed weekly schedule may miss a problem in a high-consumption reef.
Digital (Hanna) or titration (Salifert / Red Sea)?
Hanna colorimeters use an optical reading; visual kits ask you to judge a color or titration endpoint. Both depend on correct sampling, clean vials, and the stated procedure. Compare the published range and accuracy for the exact model. Buy the instrument once, then compare reagent costs separately.
Why do two kits disagree on the same water?
First check the units, sample volume, reagent expiry, and instructions for each kit. Do not multiply a Salifert phosphate result by a phosphorus conversion factor just because another instrument is used. A phosphate reading and a phosphorus reading are different units; only convert when the specific instructions require it. Repeat an unexpected reading before changing dosing.
Do ICP tests replace test kits?
No. A lab report covers the tests listed by that lab; it does not provide live monitoring between samples. Check the actual analytes and turnaround before ordering. Keep an at-home testing plan that matches your tank and dosing routine.
Reading high nitrate or phosphate? The water change calculator turns the number into a plan, and the carbon dosing guide covers export when dilution isn't enough. Dosing to targets: the dosing calculator.
Free — one email
The Reef Gear Cheat Sheet.
The exact skimmer / pump / light picks by tank size, plus our full build-cost worksheet — as one email, no spam.
Prefer the browser? Read the cheat sheet now.
One email with the sheet. If we ever start a newsletter, you can opt out first. Privacy